Best kohl eyeliner
What eyeliner colors are best for older women?
All products featured on Allure are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Softest eyeliner pencil Since water-activated eyeliners are water-based, unfortunately most are not waterproof, so if you shed a tear or go outside in the rain, it could move around. “In general, they are fairly long-lasting and smudge-proof, however they are not as long lasting compared to using an oil-based eyeliner, such as a gel,” Reader says.
Best drugstore long wear eyeliner
If you're not the type to settle for a basic black liner, this metallic formula is the shade-shifter you need in your vanity. Available in four smudgeproof iridescent shades, these colors transform shades depending on how the light hits them. But for the days when a classic black can't be beaten, the opposite side also boasts an inky liquid liner to give you a crisp cat eye. Best Multitasking Eyeliner Pencil Even with saving $2 by forgoing the sharpener, this is one of the pricier eyeliners on our list
Pat McGrath Labs Perma Precision Liquid Eyeliner
This pigmented kohl comes in four shades and glides easily on the skin. It’s a pretty long staying one and the shades are quite unique. While the blue and black are more suited for bold eye makeup looks, the green and the brown ones are more understated and subtle. Best Colored Smudge-Proof Eyeliner This best-selling drugstore eyeliner has over 1,000 five-star reviews—and we're not surprised! The ultra-smooth formula glides on for the easiest cat eye ever. Best of all, it's available in four colors.
Award winning eyeliner
At just $11, this pencil won't break the bank and hits on just about everything you need in a good eyeliner. It applies on the skin smoothly and is incredibly long-lasting. In fact, this Sephora pick will hold up through humidity, rain, tears, and oily eyelids thanks to its impressive waterproof formula. It also comes in a whopping 24 shades in a variety of finishes, so you really have the chance to create fun looks. Because of its amazing color payoff and wear, celebrity makeup artist Billie Gene says this budget pick is his favorite eyeliner. Our top picks for the best gel eyeliners in 2022: "With this eyeliner, my eyes looked greener than ever before! I loved how they looked and how it held the whole day!" —Alice Sungurov, Editorial Commerce Producer
